Common Mistakes

Reviewing the Mock SBA feedback and observations from past S.5 cohorts, these are the top 10 mistakes that lose marks. Read this before every practice session.

The Top 10 (in order of damage)

❌ 1. Reading from your notecard (drops you to 3 marks)

The rubric explicitly says: "dependence on notes (3 marks); wholly spoken from notes (2 marks)."

Why it happens: anxiety, plus a notecard with full sentences.

Fix:

• Limit each bullet to 5 words max.
• During prep, whisper-read your card and delete anything you'd read verbatim.
• During the exam, put the card down when you start speaking.

→ More in Notecard Template.

❌ 2. Saying "I agree" with no extension

Why it loses marks: the rubric for II. Communication Strategies asks you to "respond naturally & show listening" AND "build on each other's points". A bare "I agree" only does half the job.

Fix: train the 3-word rule. After every "I agree", you must add at least 3 more words:

"I agree" → "I agree, and what's more,…" / "I agree, especially because…" / "I agree, but I'd push it further…"

❌ 3. Plot summary as your answer

The Mock SBA feedback emphasises ideas + organisation. Summarising what happened is the baseline, not the answer.

Bad:

"In the play, Macbeth meets the witches. Then he goes home. Then Lady Macbeth tells him to kill the king. Then he kills the king. Then he becomes king…"

Good (P.E.E.L):

"My point is that Macbeth's downfall isn't caused by the witches — it's caused by his choice to listen to them. The reason is that Banquo gets the same prophecy and does nothing wrong. For example, Banquo even warns Macbeth that 'instruments of darkness tell us truths' to win us over. This connects to our world today: bad advice doesn't make us evil — what we choose to do with it does."

❌ 4. The missing "L" (no Link)

P.E.E.L answers without the Link are the most common drop from band 5 to band 4.

Why it happens: students plan Point + Example, but forget to make it matter to today.

Fix: before any P.E.E.L answer, set a mental flag: "My Link will be ____."

Templates for the Link:

• "This still happens today in ____."
• "Hong Kong students experience this when ____."
• "What strikes me 400 years later is ____."
• "If Shakespeare set this in 2026, he'd probably show ____."

❌ 5. Mispronouncing character names

The Mock SBA feedback section on Pronunciation & Delivery highlights:

"text to speech (Word/pdf/AI…) for names of characters/stories."

If you say "Mac-beeth" instead of "mək-BETH" through the whole exam, you'll lose pronunciation marks.

Fix: the night before, use Word's Read Aloud on:

• Macbeth, Banquo, Macduff, Duncan, Malcolm
• Romeo, Juliet, Mercutio, Tybalt, Friar Laurence
• Bassanio, Portia, Shylock, Antonio

Listen 3×, repeat each name 3× out loud.

❌ 6. Dominating the discussion (or staying silent)

Examiners need to hear all 3–4 voices. Silence and dominance both lose marks for the whole group.

If you tend to dominate:

• Set a mental limit: 20 seconds per turn.
• End each turn by passing: "…what do you think, Aisha?"

If you tend to be silent:

• Pre-load 3 short reactions on your notecard ("That's a great point because…").
• Aim to speak in the first 90 seconds — once you've spoken, momentum is easier.

❌ 7. Vague vocabulary

Bad: "It was very, very bad. The thing she did was just very bad."

Good: "It was a deeply troubling decision — ruthless, even. Lady Macbeth's manipulation was so calculated that…"

Fix: memorise the vocabulary cheatsheet in Vocabulary & Language. Use 2 power words per minute of speaking — that's only 16–24 words over 8–12 minutes, very achievable.

❌ 8. Inaccurate plot facts

Examiners notice when you say something wrong about the booklet. It signals you haven't read carefully.

Top facts to get right:

• Lady Macbeth did not kill Duncan herself.
• The witches did not cast a spell — they only predicted.
• Fleance (Banquo's son) escaped.
• Romeo was in love with Rosaline that morning.
• Juliet was about 13–14, not adult.
• Shylock did not kill Antonio — Portia stopped him.
• Antonio's ships were later found — he didn't lose his fortune.

→ See Macbeth common mistakes, Romeo common mistakes, Merchant common mistakes.

❌ 9. Trying to sound "Shakespearean"

"Verily, thou art correct, mine companion…" — no.

The Nesbit retelling uses modern prose. Your discussion should sound like a thoughtful TED Talk, not a costume drama.

Stick with phrases like:

• "From my perspective…"
• "What strikes me is…"
• "It seems to me that…"
• "If I had to choose…"

❌ 10. Talking about groupmates instead of to them

Bad: "She said something about the witches being symbols of fate."

Good (look at her, address her directly): "You said the witches are symbols of fate — I find that really interesting because…"

Direct address signals genuine listening — a marker of high Communication Strategies marks.

---

The "secondary 10" (less damaging but still avoidable)

11. Starting every sentence with "I think" — vary with "From my view…", "It seems to me…", "Personally…".
12. Long fillers: "um", "like", "basically" — replace with a 1-second silence.
13. Not using page numbers when quoting — "On P.5" is free marks.
14. Awkward laughter to fill space — better to pause and think.
15. Saying "good question!" to a teacher prompt — sounds patronising; just answer it.
16. Wandering off-topic to current events with no link back — anchor it: "…which connects back to the play because…".
17. Apologising for English: "Sorry my English is not so good" — never say this. Just speak.
18. Looking at the table instead of at people. Eye contact is graded under Delivery.
19. Speaking in past tense throughout even though Shakespeare's themes are timeless — switch to present: "Macbeth shows us that…" (literary present).
20. Wrapping up too early ("That's all I have to say") — instead, pass the topic: "I'll leave it there — Mei, what would you add?"

---

Mistakes the Mock SBA feedback specifically called out

The official feedback on A Midsummer Night's Dream (which uses the same rubric) singled out these positive examples — meaning the absence of these traits will lose you marks:

Feedback point	What you should do
"Respond naturally & show listening"	"I agree with you." + "I like your point that…"
"Build on each other's points"	"That reminds me…" / "Building on what you said…"
"Add details/examples to the discussion"	Always cite a specific moment from the booklet
"Paraphrase"	Restate a groupmate's idea before adding your own
"P.E.E.L structure"	Point → Explanation → Example → Link, every major answer
"Make in-depth points and reflective links"	The "L" connects the 400-year-old text to us today

---

The 5 most damaging combinations

These are the patterns that drop a "good" SBA to a "weak" one. Watch for these in your practice recordings:

1. Soft voice + reading from notes → both Delivery AND Vocabulary tank.
2. Long monologue + no eye contact → looks like a memorised script.
3. "I agree" + plot summary → no Communication, no Ideas.
4. Strong vocabulary + completely wrong plot facts → examiner stops trusting you.
5. Great Point + great Example + no Link → top marks impossible in Ideas.

If you can fix any 2 of these 5, you'll likely jump a full mark band.

---

A 30-second self-debrief after every practice

Ask yourself out loud:

1. Did I read from my notes? (Yes/No)
2. Did I extend at least once after "I agree"? (Yes/No)
3. Did I make at least one Link? (Yes/No)
4. Did I invite a quieter speaker? (Yes/No)
5. Did I get any plot facts wrong? (Yes/No)

3+ "good" answers = you're at band 5. 5/5 = you're at band 6.

---

Next: On the Day (6 July) — your morning checklist and what to do in the hour before.